Middle East
2:42 am
Wed February 27, 2013

Syrian Rebels, Secular And Islamist, Both Claim The Future

Originally published on Wed February 27, 2013 7:17 pm

Syria's Islamists have grown in influence as the war against President Bashar Assad's government grinds on. They have proved to be effective fighters, well armed and funded.

But as Islamists have grown stronger on the battlefield, more Syrians are asking about their political ideas and what that will mean for the future of the country.

A recent confrontation between liberal protesters and Islamists in the northwestern Syrian city of Saraqeb, which was caught on video, set off a heated online debate.

These weekly demonstrations have become a battle of symbols. Most demonstrators carry the green, red, black and white flag that was adopted by the secular opposition in the early days of the revolt.

But these days, a black banner also flutters at Friday demonstrations. It represents Salafists who embrace an ultraconservative brand of Islam that is new in Syria.

The chants and counterchants are telling: The secular liberals shout for unity, freedom and a civil state. Democracy is what they say they want.

The Islamists turn up the volume with calls for religious rule. An Islamic state is what they demand.

The Rise Of The Salafists

More than 40,000 viewers downloaded this street debate. Secular activists, especially in the capital, Damascus, raised this question on Facebook: Are the Salafists hijacking the revolt?

In some parts of Syria, they are, says Andrew Tabler at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy.

"The role of Salafists in general, publicly, has skyrocketed," he says. "They have a donor base, they are organized, and they've been able to carve out a niche in parts of Syria."

Their funding comes from private sources in the Arabian Peninsula. Moderate rebel groups, who hoped the West would back them, haven't gotten nearly the same support, says Tabler.

"The Salafists stepped in to fill the gap, they did, and they are simply making advances and capturing weapons stocks," he adds. "People like what those groups are doing. They are pushing Assad back. And nothing sells like success."

A Secular, Salafi Debate

That success has prompted other Syrian groups to debate Salafists directly, which included a recent meeting in a hotel in southern Turkey.

On one side of the table was a Salafi leader who came from inside Syria. On the other side was a group of Syrian Christians that included a female activist, a respected political writer and a priest.

Father Spiridon Tanous, the Orthodox priest, explained he wanted a dialogue between Muslims who say they want an Islamic state, and Christians who insist that democracy is the only system that guarantees the rights of minorities in Syria.

"It's not an easy discussion," Tanous acknowledged. "Personally, I don't accept ... my country as an Islamic country, because it's not like that. But we have to discuss. You cannot say no and just leave. No, because they are Syrian also."

Getting to know each other was positive, said Michel Kilo, a veteran dissident and a Syrian Christian. The age differences were striking. Kilo is part of an older generation that has long opposed the Assad regime. The young Salafists have been empowered by the war, he said, and insist on an Islamic state.

"They did not put beautiful words or package things for us," he said. "They said their opinions with clarity and honesty. Even though they know their opinions will not please us, they spoke with honesty."

Kilo spoke honestly, too. The majority of Syrians, he told them, want democracy and elections to decide what Syria will become.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

LINDA WERTHEIMER, HOST:

This is MORNING EDITION from NPR News. I'm Linda Wertheimer.

RENEE MONTAGNE, HOST:

And I'm Renée Montagne. In Syria's Islamists have grown in influence as the rebellion grinds on against the Assad regime. These Islamists have proven to be effective on the battlefield - well armed and well funded - but more Syrians are now asking about their political ideas and what those ideas might mean for the country's future. NPR's Deborah Amos reports from Gaziantep on Turkey's border with Syria.

DEBORAH AMOS, BYLINE: This confrontation, caught on video, between liberal protestors and Islamists, set off a heated online debate in Syria. These weekly demonstrations have become a battle of symbols. Most carry the green, red and white revolution flag adopted in the early days of the revolt. But these days, a black banner is also waved at Friday demonstrations. It represents Salafis who embrace an ultra conservative brand of Islam that is new in Syria. The chants and counter chants in the large town of Saraqeb are telling.

(SOUNDBITE OF DEMONSTRATION)

UNIDENTIFIED GROUP: (chanting in foreign language)

AMOS: The liberals shout for unity, freedom, and a civil state - democracy is what they say they want.

(SOUNDBITE OF DEMONSTRATION)

UNIDENTIFIED GROUP: (chanting in foreign language)

AMOS: Islamists turn up the volume with calls for religious rule. An Islamic state is what they demand. More than 40,000 viewers downloaded this street debate. Secular activists, especially in Damascus, raised this question on Facebook: Are the Salafis hijacking the revolt? In some parts of Syria, they are, says Andrew Tabler at the Washington Institute for Near East Studies, as Salafis move to the mainstream of the revolution.

ANDREW TABLER: The role of Salafis, in general, publicly, has skyrocketed. They have a donor base, they are organized and they're able to carve out a niche in parts of Syria.

AMOS: Their funding comes from private sources in the Arabian Peninsula. Moderate rebel groups, who hoped the West would back them, haven't gotten nearly the same support, says Tabler.

TABLER: The Salafis stepped in to fill the gap, they did, and they are simply making advances and capturing weapon stocks. People like what those groups are doing, they are pushing Assad back. And nothing sells like success.

AMOS: That success has prompted other Syrian groups to debate Salafis directly. This meeting in a hotel in southern Turkey was the first of its kind. On one side of the table, a Salafist leader who came from inside Syria. On the other side, a group of Syrian Christians; that included a female activist, a respected political writer, and a priest.

FATHER SPIRIDON TANOUS: My name is Father Spiridon Tanous, we are Orthodox. Of course, my origin is Syrian.

AMOS: Father Tanous explained he wanted a dialogue between Muslims who say they want an Islamic state, and Christians who insist that democracy is the only system that guarantees the rights of minorities in Syria.

TANOUS: It's not easy discussion, not easy discussion.

AMOS: Did you expect it would be? This is the first time you've ever met.

TANOUS: Yeah, this is first time. Of course, personally, I don't accept to see my country as an Islamic country, because it's not like that. But we have to discuss. You cannot say no and just leave. No, because they are Syrian also.

AMOS: Getting to know each other was positive, said Michel Kilo, a veteran dissident, a Syrian Christian. It's my duty to talk to them, he added. The difference in age was striking. Kilo is part of an older generation that long opposed the Assad regime. These young Salafis have been empowered by the war, he, said, and insist on an Islamic state.

MICHEL KILO: (through translator) They did not put beautiful words or package things for us. They said their opinion with clarity and honesty. Even though they know their opinions will not please us, they spoke with honesty.

AMOS: Kilo spoke honestly, too. The majority of Syrians want democracy - elections, he told them - to decide what Syria will become. Deborah Amos, NPR News, Gaziantep. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Related program: